Moderator: Super Moderators








Cataphract wrote:Ugh... coin mail. Why, oh why, dear GR, did you have to perpetuate all the annoying fallacies? WHY?

Pappystein wrote:Cataphract wrote:Ugh... coin mail. Why, oh why, dear GR, did you have to perpetuate all the annoying fallacies? WHY?
Why indeed. Of all the known Coin mails in the world, most have been since debunked as forgeries and the few that remain are cerimonial armors and never were worn in combat. Lets face it, in game stats for Coin mail are WAY wrong. The closest in game armor time to Coin Mail is really Splint Mail. That being said, it is in the rules and I am using it.
If you want to talk about broken rules. Why isn't there rules for Half plate being properly fitted in this system (or any other for that matter?) After all Full Plate is for Horse bound combat not foot combat. Half Plate was created so a Knight could work well on the ground, not because he was lacking funds like EVERY GAME system seems to portray. One of my Character's goals is to have a well fitted suit of Castle forged Half Plate armor for ground combat. I will be talking with my GM today about the eventual purchase of a convertable set of Full/Half Plate armor for my Character that I can buy Piecemeal. In one of Green Ronin's DnD suplments they had such an armor available.



I get really confused about all the branches of House Flint too, especially after Dance with Dragons! Mind you, DwD portaryed them as pretty badass, so they should be fun allies.We've heard a bit about the other branches of the family in the books, Flints of Widow's Watch, and apparently a clan of Flints in the northern hills?


Eisen wrote:We're starting about a year before the events of Game of Thrones, but once it hits the fan you can bet House Milo will be right in the thick of things. Weather or not anyone manages to survive is another question...
Also some of my players are slackers and haven't read the books so if we could avoid spoilers I'd be greatful



Carriker wrote:
Eisen, you mentioned the possibility of running into the events of Game of Thrones in your game. How common is this? Is that what other folks usually do? I warned my players that, depending on what happens in this game, there were no guarantees of the events in the books even necessarily happening in my game - I may just decide to do something else entirely with the setting.
Thanks again for sharing your game with us.

I warned my players that, depending on what happens in this game, there were no guarantees of the events in the books even necessarily happening in my game - I may just decide to do something else entirely with the setting.

Pappystein wrote:Carriker wrote:
Eisen, you mentioned the possibility of running into the events of Game of Thrones in your game. How common is this? Is that what other folks usually do? I warned my players that, depending on what happens in this game, there were no guarantees of the events in the books even necessarily happening in my game - I may just decide to do something else entirely with the setting.
Thanks again for sharing your game with us.
As the Common sense/Physics Lawyer/House Rule creator for our South of the North Campaign, I can tell you there are several reasons Eisen rightfully feels we can fit in with the cannon books/show.
Simply put however, It is easy to stay within a given Mythos. Provide the GM uses ALL the tools available to them. Most in-experienced GMs fear the use of the BEST pair of tools to keep the party on Cannon.
1) PC Manipulation
2) Mr Plot Stick.
Judicious use of those two tools will keep a campaign on track to remain within Cannon. OVER or HEAVY HANDED use of those two tools will De-rail a campaign at the drop of a hat.
That being said, there are very few people who don't try to stick to cannon in my experience. Most of the GMs fail miserably in attempting to do so but that does not mean it wasn't their goal.
Hope that is helpful





Carriker wrote:In my own home game, "To Find a Way, or Make One" (which is the motto of the PC House), I've got one player who has read the whole series, one who has only seen the Game of Thrones HBO show, and another who had only seen the show but has now started reading the series. I don't honestly find it necessary for my players to read the books, personally. I like for them to have at least seen the series, so they get an idea of what the setting is like, to some degree.
Eisen, you mentioned the possibility of running into the events of Game of Thrones in your game. How common is this? Is that what other folks usually do? I warned my players that, depending on what happens in this game, there were no guarantees of the events in the books even necessarily happening in my game - I may just decide to do something else entirely with the setting.
Thanks again for sharing your game with us.

Return to A Song of Ice and Fire RPG
Users browsing this forum: HurricaneEm and 3 guests