superbat_99 wrote:You should remember though that long range weapons are in yards so 600 feet is only going to be 200 yards. So at most archers are going to be taking a -2D on any attacks. Which means a really good archer will be able to reach the top and hit something while most of the rabble probably will not.
This is where you start having problems with a non-complicated system. You lose a lot of range firing a bow in an almost vertical trajectory (hence the benefit of having the high ground in a battle). IMO, I would have to say that a Wildling archer should have double the normal penalty for that kind of shot (-4D) to hit a target on The Wall.